Getting food delivered to the house, in the woodsy western end of town, can be challenging. And visitors have described it as remote. But being off the beaten path has benefits: Hessian Lake, at Bear Mountain, where the paths are ideal for early-morning jogs, is a quick drive.
“You may feel secluded sometimes, but you do have neighbors,” she said. “They’re just not on top of you.”
Michael Nocera, 31, an officer with the New York City Police Department, was also feeling claustrophobic in the city, where he was renting a two-bedroom apartment in his mother’s rowhouse in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn.
“I wanted a backyard, and I wanted a house that wasn’t touching other buildings,” Mr. Nocera said. “But on a cop’s salary, you really can’t afford Brooklyn.”
The town of Warwick, in Orange County, was too rural, he said, and the housing stock in Haverstraw showed its age. But Stony Point delivered, with a three-bedroom, ranch-style house with a finished basement for $358,000. “You couldn’t touch Manhattan for that,” he said.
Neighbors showed up to say hello on move-in day last summer, some of whom were active or retired police officers. “It’s a very close community,” said Mr. Nocera, who lives with his wife, Monique, 31, who works in the fragrance industry, and their 18-month-old son, a potential candidate for a local tee-ball league for 3-year-olds and up.